By: Kathleen Porter Mcgee
There has
been an ongoing debate about Common Core and I am sure there will continue to
be one for a very long time. The common core fascinates me. I love seeing and
hearing all different peoples’ opinions. The article that struck me most was,
“Implementing the Common Core with struggling Readers” by Kathleen Porter. I
also found myself so interested in the topic that I searched around to other
sites looking for information dealing with the same topic. I wanted to hear the
voice of others as well.
The article
discusses that the many states that want teachers to implement CCSS will result
in a large population of students who are struggling with reading and writing.
Mcgee
states, “CCSS focused squarely on three things: choosing great texts,
writing great questions, and giving students just enough in the way of
vocabulary and background along the way that will help them understand and
grapple with the texts.” Of course we already knew this….well if you keep up
with the standards, but what do those do that struggle with reading? What about
the students who should be reading at a grade four level but are still reading
at a grade 2 level? Do you give them books that they should be reading
according to the ccss or do you give them the “easier” books so that the text
complexity is not to difficult?
The
question that was raised in this article was, “We still hear all too often that
we should “wait” to have students engage in difficult texts until they’re
ready. Lemov and his team were determined to put that myth to rest from the
start. And throughout the session, the guidance and the questions from the
teachers focused not on whether students
could read and analyze the texts but rather on how teachers
could help them do so.” (Mcgee 2)
As many
know the common core were standards created so that students will all be at the
same level when the finish that level of schooling. Did people stop and think
about the students that do not learn as fast as others? Or ones who have
learning delays? An argument is Common Core in conflict with itself
because the standards say that that all students should be reading complex,
grade-level texts by the end of the school year. If a teacher decides to offer
English language learners or developing readers texts they can learn from,
texts two to four years below grade level, the teacher uses his decision-making
power under “the reader and the task” — but his students’ won’t be reading on
grade level by the end of the year. (Robb. 2)
Some
ideas to help push students to get to the common core ready level are as
follows: (berg 1)
·
Significantly increase word knowledge
through a new way of using word walls, vocabulary choice, strategies, and the
love of words
·
Engage your most challenging readers
with high-impact strategies that increase motivation and increase time-on-task
·
· Increase your use of
Digital Literacy Resources to help your struggling students
· nnovative vocabulary,
fluency and background knowledge strategies
to boost reading achievement and maintain the rigorous expectations identified
in the Common Core State Standards
I would just suggest that teachers need to work extra hard
with students that are not at the “suggested” level and rate that is
implemented in the common core. Everyone needs to realize that no two students
are the same and it takes some longer than others to figure things out…but
eventually they will figure it out.
Goodwin, Denise. "The Most
Effective Strategies to Help Your Struggling Readers Meet the Common Core State
Standards for Reading." Bureau of Education & Research. N.p.,
n.d. Web. 16 Nov. 2014
Mcgee, Kathleen. "Implementing the
Common Core with Struggling Readers." The Thomas B. Fordham Institute.
N.p., 16 May 2014. Web. 16 Nov. 2014.